Michaella had an eventful reunion — she revealed she dated another season 11 contestant and later took an unexpected tumble on stage

NEED TO KNOW

• Michaella Giorgio tripped over her dress while joining castmates to support Sarah Williams at the season 11 Love Is Blind reunion
• During the episode, she revealed a brief secret romance with costar Matt Waldrip
• The Love Is Blind season 11 reunion is streaming now on Netflix

Michaella Giorgio had more than one unexpected moment during the Love Is Blind season 11 reunion on Nov. 8.

The reality star revealed she had a secret romance with another contestant following her split from Rob Feeley — but that wasn’t the only surprise. Michaella also took an awkward tumble off the couch as her fellow castmates gathered to comfort Sarah Williams following a bombshell cheating confession from her husband, John Shannon.

During the reunion, Michaella and Rob reflected on their failed relationship, with Michaella admitting she had felt abandoned and rejected by the man she once envisioned becoming her family.

Rob, meanwhile, opened up about his experience in therapy following their breakup, earning praise from co-host Nick Lachey.

As the former couple discussed their relationship, their fellow contestants weighed in on what went wrong. Erika Ellis described their romance as chaotic, while Morrey Eglin, who considers Rob his best friend, joked that the conversation felt like attending his funeral.

Morrey also expressed his belief that the pair had been right for each other, but Love Is Blind was not the right environment.

The conversation took another turn when it was revealed that Michaella had also been romantically involved with fellow season 11 contestant Matt Waldrip.

Matt claimed their relationship had been meaningful to him and revealed he had fallen in love with Michaella. Michaella, however, had a different perspective on their brief romance.

She insisted the relationship only lasted a few weeks and said she had not been in love with Matt, despite having told him otherwise. When the subject of her declaration of love came up, Michaella revealed she had been on mushrooms when she told Matt she loved him.

The revelation prompted another reaction from Morrey, who jokingly asked whether he should take Matt out or muzzle him.

Later in the reunion, Michaella found herself at the center of another memorable moment. The conversation shifted to John and Sarah’s marriage, and John admitted to exchanging graphic text messages with a stripper.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Sarah claimed John had frequently insulted her, including calling her “dumb,” and said the messages ultimately became the final straw in their marriage. As the emotional conversation unfolded, the women of the cast gathered around Sarah to embrace her and offer their support.

During that touching moment, as Michaella got up from the couch to comfort Sarah, she tripped over her dress and fell on stage.

She rebounded, laughing, saying, “All to hug you!”

“Who needs a Cam joke when we have Michaella?” Co-host Vanessa Lachey said.

“You’re welcome guys,” joked Michaella.

Love Is Blind season 11 is streaming on Netflix. 

#Love #Blinds #Michaella #Giorgio #Falls #Awkward #Reunion #Moment #Reveals #Secret #Romance #Fellow #Contestant