Burnham and Badenoch clash over welfare
Badenoch says that reply makes it sound like Burnham is not planning cuts. He says young people cannot wait 10 years. With Burnham, everything takes 10 years, she says.
She says working-age welfare is set to rise.
Keir Starmer could not make welfare cuts because MPs now in Burnham’s cabinet led a rebellion against it. That shows they are the welfare party.
Burnham says Badenoch only ever asks for cuts.
He says Helen Whately, the shadow DWP secretary, said hundreds of thousands of disabled people would lose benefits under Tory plans.
The biggest rise in Neets came under the Tories, he says.
He says he will give hope to young people.
Key events
Home Office says policing in England and Wales to be based on 200 ‘local commands’ as part of biggest reforms since 1800s
Policing in England and Wales will be restructured into about 200 local commands, Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, has said.
Under what the Home Office claims will be “the biggest reforms to policing in 200 years”, the government will set up around 200 new “local police commands” (LPCs). They will deal with routine crime like burglary, vehicle theft and antisocial behaviour.
Announcing the changes, the Home Office said:
Since the government unveiled plans in January to fundamentally restructure the policing model, much focus has been on reducing the number of forces at a regional level.
However, delivering a keynote speech to police leaders today, Shabana Mahmood announced she will build a structure from the bottom up with a larger number of smaller commands that will focus solely on the needs of their local area.
LPCs will be the foundation of the new policing model, focused on keeping neighbourhoods safe and tackling crimes like burglary, vehicle theft, phone theft and antisocial behaviour.
Each one will be situated closer to the areas they serve, with decision making driven by local knowledge and understanding.
Broadly aligned to the geographical boundaries of councils, LPCs will cover towns or rural areas. This will also allow police to work in closer partnership with other local services such as probation, health and housing and improve outcomes.
A new local police guarantee will ensure every LPC delivers the same high-quality local policing, no matter where in the country they serve.
The Home Office said that this move would be the first step towards a wider programme of police reform. There are 43 police forces in England and Wales and in January Mahmood published a white paper setting out plans for some of them to be merged. The Home Office has been looking at plans for a much smaller number of regional police forces, but progress has been held up because how these would fit alongside Andy Burnham’s plans to give mayoral authorities more say over policing remains unresolved.
The Home Office news release suggests LPCs will be at the bottom of the policing pyramid, and the National Police Service at the top. It does not say what happens in between.
It explains:
Every LPC will have a named commander, accountable to their local community and elected officials, with communities able to have a role in setting their local priorities.
Above them will sit specialist services that will lead investigations on the most serious and complex crimes. They will be responsible for delivering specialist functions such as public order, forensics and firearms.
This will guarantee that no matter where anyone is, they will have access to expert specialist policing which the current system does not provide.
The new system will also remove the administrative duplication that exists across the existing 43 police headquarters, freeing up thousands of police officers to return to neighbourhood policing.
The final structure within policing would be the National Police Service which will tackle nationwide and international threats.
It will bring together the world-leading capabilities of Counter Terrorism Policing and other agencies, ensuring that policing has the technology, intelligence and resources needed to tackle crime in the 21st century.
Burnham says Badenoch should withdraw ‘crass’ comment defending disability cuts on grounds ‘amputees run marathons’
Andy Burnham has said that Kemi Badenoch should withdraw her “crass and insensitive” comment justifying cuts to disability benefits on the grounds that “double amputees run marathons”.
After Badenoch used this line in a speech last week, the Paralympian Richard Whitehead posted a message on Facebook criticising her. He said:
Disability should never be judged through isolated examples of individual achievement, but through an understanding of the barriers people and families face every day.
The fact that some double-leg amputees can run marathons does not mean that disability support is unnecessary. Equally, the fact that some people with ADHD thrive despite limited support does not mean that others do not need meaningful assistance.
In subsequent remarks, Whitehead said that Badenoch’s comments were “divisive” and that he was “gobsmacked that somebody’s sporting success would be weaponised in this way”.
At PMQs today, the Labour MP Charlotte Nichols asked Burnham whether he agreed with Whitehead that “the achievements of our sports men and women with disabilities should never be weaponised against others”.
Burnham replied:
I thought the comments by Richard Whitehead do deserve a response from the right honourable lady [Badenoch]. They were crass and insensitive, and I think she should withdraw them.
Whitehead has run more than 100 marathons, set world records and won four Paralympic medals.
PMQs – snap verdict
Guardian readers probably don’t need much persuading that PMQs is a terrible forum for reasonable debate, and there was a good example today that shows why. In his final response to Kemi Badenoch, Burnham accused her of adopting a “patronising tone”. This was uncharacteristically personal, and it lit up on social media as about the most interesting line from the exchange, with some commentators implying it was a gaffe. In reality, of course, it was probably one of the least contentious things Burnham said. Badenoch is patronising, particularly at PMQs. If there were a world championships for being patronising, she would be leading the UK team. Yet Burnham will probably conclude that it was a mistake, and something he shouldn’t have said.
Why? Because it made him look a bit rattled. Burnham came into office determined to pursue “problem solving, not point scoring”, but increasingly that is looking like a lost cause and the centrifugal power of PMQs yanks him back into a slanging match. (He is not always like this with opposition backbenchers, but he is – inevitably – with Badenoch.) Today, speaking to the Tory leader, he seemed to devote more time than ever to attacking her party’s record, rather than seeking common ground. On the plus side, the points he was making about the Conservatives’ record, and about her policy agenda now consisting of little more than welfare cuts, were forceful. On the negative side, he sounded like someone on the defensive.
Just as she did last week, Badenoch was reasonably good at delivering the sort of broad-brush ‘You’re rubbish’ messaging that would work as a headline for a Daily Express op ed. But it was hard to discern what particular attack line she wanted to land. There was a time when she would arrive at PMQs with a pre-prepared gotcha question and afterwards, normally following Keir Starmer’s refusal to answer, CCHQ would send out a press release highlighting the alleged implications of the question-dodging. There was none of that today, or last week.
One of Badenoch’s most interesting claims was that Burnham is just offering the “vibes” of welfare reform, not the real thing. But that claim is so wide of the mark it is unlikely to work even with a Tory audience. The Milburn plan may have its drawbacks, but it is absurd to dismiss it as just vibes.
Sky News also set Badenoch up for another attack, highlighting Alan Milburn saying yesterday that some people would lose from the reforms, while Burnham said in a separate interview he did not want anyone to lose out. It was a classic case of apples and pears; Milburn was saying people will lose out from the benefit cuts, while Burnham was saying that, because those cuts are part of a strategy intended to divert off benefits into work, in the long run they wouldn’t lose out. Mindful, perhaps, of the ‘if you’re explaining, you’re losing’ theory of political communications, Burnham did not want to clarify this, and he just sidestepped her question. Badenoch then did not pursue the point, which was strange because a follow-up question could have made it much more awkward for him.
Layla Moran (Lib Dem) asks if the government will act to stop non-disclosure agreements being used by rich and powerful people to silence vulnerable victims.
Burnham says there was action in the Employment Rights Act to tackle this, but the government could go further, he says. He says they will look to see if this can be extended to freelancers.
Ayoub Khan (Ind) asks about someone who posts online as Habibi, but who has been identifed “as Ben Tait, who has deep connections in the House of Lords”. He says this person has smeared MPs and peers, and incited religious hatred. But he has been praised by a shadow justice minister, he says.
Burnham says he does not know the details. This sounds like an issue for the Tories, he says. But he says he will arrange a meeting for Khan about this.
Andrew George (Lib Dem) says the budget will reward second home owners who let their homes. They will get a tax benefit. This is public money that could be better spent helping people in housing need.
And he says he was disappointed his private member’s bill on this did not get government support.
Burnham says he asked officials to look seriously at the bill. “It was felt that it wasn’t the best way to address the issues, but we don’t disagree with what he’s trying to do,” he says. He says he will arrange for the housing minister to meet George.
Shivani Raja (Con) says Leicestershire police has been “issuing dual identity warrant cards for gender fluid officers”. She says that is absurd, and she urges the government to stop this.
Burnham says the government has been “relentless in tackling violence against women and girls in every single respect”. He says he is not aware of this issue, but will look into it.
Martin Vickers (Con) asks if Scunthorpe will be a priority for the strategic sites accelerator programme?
Burnham says he would encourage the area to put in an application.
Andrew Ranger (Lab) asks about the flytipping problem in Wrexham. Will the PM urge the Welsh government to give Wrexham council more powers to tackle this?
Burnham says he is encouraging the Welsh government to devolve powers further down.
Caroline Voaden (Lib Dem) says fishermen in Brixham can barely afford to go out because fuel costs are so high. Will the government help them?
Burnham says the government has acted on fuel duty. But there is probably more to be done, he says.
Charlie Dewhirst (Con) asks if the government will prioritise British jobs when investing in military satellite capability.
Burnham says he cannot comment because that is a question about a live procurement decision.
Gill German (Lab) asks the government to invest more in the rail system in North Wales.
Burnham says he thinks the rail system in North Wales “does need to be better”.
Dave Doogan, the SNP leader at Westminster, says Brexit has been a disaster. But he claims Burnham is being queasy about moving away from Keir Starmer’s red lines. When will he commit to rejoining the EU?
Burnham says he is leading on Europe. But he is also sticking to what he promised at the Makerfield byelection.
Burnham describes Tory MPs as pro-Brexit ‘zombies’
Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, says the Vote Leave zombies are back in force. They are trying to scare people with a new made-up number. But people can now see the true Brexit horror. Will the PM get a new deal?
Burnham says the zombies have been shouting at him. The Tories don’t like it when he says their Brexit deal did not work. Exports are down as a result. So there is a deal to be had. He says he would like to get cross-party support for a deal.
Davey urges Burnham to ditch the trade and cooperation agreement, and to negotiate an entirely new trade deal.
He asks about Nvidia, and says Donald Trump sold share in it before news of the Jensen Huang scandal broke. That is fresh evidence of corruption, he says.
Burnham says, when Trump is meeting President Xi in China tomorrow, he will be in Berlin for a meeting of the coalition of the willing. He says he is glad the Commons is united in standing up to Ukraine.
UPDATE: Burnham said:
Well, I think we heard from some of those zombies just before. They were shouting at me. But the truth is, they don’t like it when we say the truth in this House.
The truth is, the Brexit deal that they negotiated wasn’t good enough for Britain. It’s just a fact, and the vast majority of the public know that.
It’s really important that we face up to that. They burned bridges with our largest market, old friends and neighbours. They just destroyed all of those relationships.
Exports are down from their constituencies, and they know that. They know that as well.
So there is a deal in front of us on Friday. I am looking for support across the floor of this House for what we are trying to negotiate.
Jon Pearce (Lab) asks about international men’s day, and the risk of suicide.
Burnham praises organisations that work to tackle men’s suicide. He says the government has a men’s health strategy.
Badenoch says business creates growth, not government.
The only way to reduce youth unemployment is to make it easier to hire people, she says.
She says the government thinks social security is more important than national security.
It is this Labour government that is not working, she says.
Burnham says growth is up, unemployment is down.
He accuses Badenoch of asking self-serving questions and adopting a “patronising tone”.
He says Labour believe in the next generation. The Tories want to throw them on the scrap heap.
He says he is bringing back hope.
Badenoch says the Milburn report is yet again kicking things into the long grass.
And she claims unemployment is down because people are no longer looking for work.
On Friday Burnham will sign up to 100,000 people from the EU coming to the UK. Where will those jobs come from?
Burnham says under the Tories they had years of no growth. The deal with the EU will be good for growth, cutting red tape, cutting the cost of exporting, and bringing food prices down.
Families are struggling. The Tories used to back cutting red tape. But the Tories cannot stand up for this because they are split, he says.
#urges #Badenoch #withdraw #crass #defence #disability #cuts #grounds #amputees #run #marathons #politics #live #Politics