Following the conviction of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault, and the allegations of sexual misconduct levelled at David Walliams, there have been increasing calls for the government to act to protect young women. And these calls have increasingly centred on changing Britain’s age-of-consent laws.

Mia Latter, now aged 37, alleges that she was in an abusive relationship with Brand and was raped by him when she was just 16 years old. Echoing campaign groups like Close the Consent Gap, she is now calling for a new, staggered age-of-consent law, which would make it illegal for adults over a certain age to have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds. As Latter told The Sunday Times: ‘I don’t want to criminalise teenagers having sex with each other. But… if you’re in your 30s, 40s and 50s and you’re trying to have a relationship with someone under the age of 18, it [should be] a criminal offence.’

We should be very wary of these demands for a change in the law. The law is a famously blunt instrument – especially in matters of sexual consent, which is typically a private negotiation between individuals. After all, how do we frame an age-of-consent law that takes into account the complexities of power dynamics and passion? How do we stagger the age of consent, sometimes treating a young woman as a child, and sometimes as an adult?

It is not clear that there’s anything particularly wrong with the age-of-consent law as it stands. The age of sexual consent was set at 16 for girls in 1885. The decision was driven by concerns over child protection, a desire to control brothels and an effort to reduce prostitution among girls as young as 13. Like most laws that pertain to sex, it was meant to be a clear statement that sex involving under-16s is wrong. It is an example of ‘expressivist’ legislation – a legal effort to set standards rather than to create and catch criminals. It was never meant to mean that a young person’s 16th birthday is a magic door to maturity. It simply establishes that under-16s need certain protections.

Despite the hue and cry following the Brand and Walliams scandals, the existing legal framework protects young people pretty well. It is widely accepted that many teens are sexually active in their mid-teens. Rather than criminalise these teenagers, we as a society have adopted a ‘harm reduction’ model. We provide contraception and access to sexual-health services to those having sex below the age of consent – most of whom are doing so with those of a similar age. If they disclose that a ‘boyfriend’ is significantly older or in a position of authority, and abuse or coercion seems possible, those working in sexual-health services are advised to raise ‘safeguarding’ issues.


Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!




Please wait…

The sordid carryings-on of Brand are not a sensible basis for legislative review. Nor, frankly, are the regrets of a woman in her 30s about the way she behaved in her teens. As Mia Latter told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, her parents did everything they could to stop her meeting Brand for sex – her mother even met Brand and asked him to end the relationship. Yet Latter still made the decision to get into the car Brand sent to collect her from school.

We need to look with clear eyes to see the path we need to go down if we are going to deal with predatory scumbags. It may seem fair to want to protect a 16- or 17-year-old from exploitation. But if we determine that she has no capacity to consent to sex with an older man, how does that fit with the state’s recognition of her capacity to make other decisions – to drive a car, to get married, to join the armed forces and, soon, to vote?

Adolescents vary enormously in maturity and their capacity to make responsible, meaningful decisions. Transitioning into adulthood, particularly into the world of adult relationships, is difficult. But the law cannot be relied on as a chaperone. It’s true that Brand’s victims have been let down, but it’s not the consent laws that are to blame. Culpability lies with those who fail to bring up girls to have self-respect and street smarts. And it should go without saying that grown men should treat women with respect and dignity.

It is not rape apologism to suggest girls over the age of 16 are quite capable of saying No or Yes to sex. They need to understand the consequences because, in truth, that is the only way they will be safe. We don’t need a new law criminalising age-gap relationships. We need laws and an understanding of consent that convey to every woman and man that when a woman of any age says No, she means it.

Brand’s defence barrister has been accused of deploying rape myths during the trial. He questioned why Brand’s victims didn’t scream or fight back, or why they took so long to report the attack. It is true that each of these raises misconceptions about consent and trauma and risks blaming victims. Sometimes, women are not in a position to resist. But that should not stop us teaching our daughters that, whatever their age, an unambiguous refusal, a scream if there are people to hear it, and a punch in the balls are the best forms of protection you can get.

A change in the legal age of consent will do nothing to prevent perverts from preying on young women. Indeed, looking to the law for help distracts us from the one thing that might: building a culture where No means No, and women know they are fully entitled to say it.

#Changing #age #consent #wont #protect #young #women