When I was a teenager, my dad the Communist sometimes said things about his beloved Soviet Union that couldn’t be proved, as there was no internet. One was that the subways were like palaces, a claim I’ve also heard from other children of Soviet-lovers. But a more unusual one was that, in Georgia, only women past the menopause were allowed to be judges, as only they could be trusted to be dispassionate.

The Georgia claim is very niche, and I’ve never heard it from any other source. But my dad wasn’t a liar, so it stuck in my mind. In the wake of recent sex and showbiz revelations, it’s a question that I’ve asked myself: could women en masse in positions of power be trusted to behave better than men?

Up to a point, Lord Copper. I do believe that women behave better around vulnerable people than men do. One thinks of the dreadful examples of men who are meant to be protecting women (and children), but are having sex with them instead. And it’s not just the ‘peace-keeping’ forces of the United Nations on the ground, but the high-minded men at the top who allegedly can’t be trusted. This includes Luiz Loures, who stepped down as deputy chief of UNAIDS after sexual-assault allegations; the late Ruud Lubbers, who resigned as UN High Commissioner for Refugees after being accused of sexual harassment; and Temo Waqanivalu, who was sacked as a senior manager at the World Health Organisation following an internal investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct. Here in the UK, we had the case of Brendan Cox, widower of the late Jo, who resigned from More in Common and the Jo Cox Foundation in 2018 after the Mail on Sunday published allegations that he had attacked a woman in America in 2015, with the police recording her complaint as one of assault and battery. The action against him was dropped but he left Save the Children in the same year. Cox told the Mail:

‘Certainly, I had too much to drink at times. I probably behaved in a way I thought was sort of jokey or flirtatious. I often wasn’t being serious, but that was perceived differently by others. There was never any malice, any intention to upset or offend people.’

How often have we heard these weasel words? 

On the other hand, women can be just as warlike when faced with a suitable foe. Of course you get deluded females like former Irish president Mary Robinson saying that a planet on which countries were led by broads would deliver ‘a much safer’ world. Even more outrageously, former Meta chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg opined that ‘no two countries run by women would ever go to war’. But female leaders from Elizabeth I to Indira Gandhi to Margaret Thatcher never ran from a fight. And research by Abigail Post and Paromita Sen published in the Washington Post in 2019 claimed that:


Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!




Please wait…

‘The perceived strength of women – their ability to strike a compromise – is seen as weakness during a military crisis. Women must escalate the disagreement to establish resolve… We examined all female heads of state involved in military disputes with other nations between 1980 and 2010. In a statistical model, we find that women are nearly 17 percentage points more likely than their male counterparts to face resistance to their threats from international opponents (ie, other countries). Women consequently use more military force to overcome their opponent’s initial resistance.’

If politics is showbusiness for plain people, what about actual show business? Would we be better off if women had more power? There are many films about men sexually harassing women, but only poor old Michael Douglas ever seems to be sexually harassed by women (Demi Moore in Disclosure, Glenn Close in Fatal Attraction and arguably Sharon Stone in Basic Instinct). And we know that the entertainment complex is a snake-pit in which women are exploited for their brief moment of youthful beauty by older, generally ugly men, both onscreen and off. I don’t need to go into the gory details of the Harvey Weinstein case again. Rare are the cases in which the roles are seemingly reversed. In 2018, a 22-year-old actor called Jimmy Bennett claimed he had been sexually assaulted by the actress and Weinstein accuser Asia Argento when he was 17 and she was 37. Though she paid him \$380,000, Argento wrote to a friend: ‘The horny kid jumped me.’ Ironically, Bennett had appeared as Argento’s son in a film called The Heart is Deceitful Above All Things.

The casting couch was a long and shameful open secret. This has perhaps led to a situation in which the role of casting director today is unusually female-dominated, with around three-quarters of casting directors being female, as opposed to most other careers in the film industry that don’t feature a mascara wand. The explanations given usually involve wet concepts like ‘empathy’ for actors, but we all know what that means – it means that female casting directors are far less likely to corner young hopefuls and demand oral gratification in return for a walk-on part.

Similarly, it’s hard to imagine reversing the genders in the 2023 survey that stated that nearly one third of female NHS surgeons have been sexually assaulted by a colleague, often in an actual operating theatre. Education appears to be more of an equal-opportunity occupation when it comes to sexual relationships between teacher and pupil. Still, it’s difficult to envisage a female pop star writing a drooling song, like The Police’s ‘Don’t Stand So Close to Me’, about a woman teacher getting off with a boy in her care – it’s the bragging element that differentiates the sexes. I can’t imagine a male version of Lolita – only Germaine Greer dared go there with her pervy picture-book, The Boy, of which I wrote sternly in the Spectator:

‘She shouldn’t drool and dribble over nudie pics, like some pop-eyed Edwardian masher. This lack of desire to do so doesn’t indicate repression and coyness on the part of women, but rather maturity and perspective… Women can enjoy sex as much as men without falling prey to all the weird, morbid stuff that men insist on complicating a very basic and easily fulfilled appetite with; the proportion of female paedophiles, fetishists, bestialists and necrophiles is tiny. As is the number of female voyeurs, Dr Greer – and I really don’t see why it is desirable to add to their number.’

Pop stars from Gary Glitter to David Bowie pursued and preyed on underage girls. The nearest that Whataboutists can get to this in reverse is the fact that Cheryl first met the late Liam Payne when he was 14 and she was 25, when he famously winked at her as she critiqued him. He was 21 when they started dating (‘She’s been my dream girl since I was young’) and they had a baby when he was 23. It’s a world away from anonymous teenagers being brought in and dispensed, like so much merch, to men verging on the sociopathic, and the giggling gaggle of enablers who surround them.

And what of the comedy world? Male comics joke about the women they’ve fucked. Female comics joke about their last fuckable day. It’s telling that it was a female comedian – Lucy Beaumont – who had the guts to call out the Knob Club in the end, despite believing that she would be shunned by the industry for upsetting ‘The Talent’.

Katie Glass, the showbiz and sexual-politics commentator, made the point that if women were as powerful as men, they would behave like men in many ways. After all, we’ve heard about women throwing their weight around. But Glass said that she didn’t think women sexually harass or sleep with 18-year-old boys on their staff, because, as she put it, grown women mostly aren’t attracted to teenage boys: ‘Unlike men’, she said, ‘I think women on the whole look for a partner who is also interesting to talk to; women rarely enjoy the same kick from sexual dominance. On the whole, women’s sexuality is often driven by being desired – not by forcing their desire on someone else.’

As an afterthought, I Googled the Georgian judge thing – and it looks like my dad may have made it up, the scamp. But as lying men go, I was lucky to know such a good one.

#Powerful #men #behaving #badly #spiked