Welcome to the conversation

Illuminated COP31 Türkiye Antalya sign glows on a building under a crescent moon at night
COP31 climate summit is taking place in Turkiye’s Antalya Photograph: Ayse Eda Unlu Ozen/Anadolu/Getty Images

The Cop31 climate summit in Antalya is in its final days, and negotiators are fighting over a first draft of the deal.

It calls for “accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels, including through the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems”, and for tripling adaptation finance for poorer countries. But with the world heading past the 1.5C limit and countries deeply divided over finance, adaptation and the “just transition”, can Cop31 deliver anything that matters?

The Guardian’s environment editor, Fiona Harvey, reported that the 18-page draft contains 144 separate items, many of which are unlikely to survive: “There are still at least four and a half days of heavy negotiating to go, so this text will go through many more iterations.” Campaigners are sceptical. Tzeporah Berman of the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative said: “This mention in the draft text will last about 2 minutes and they know it.”

Ministers have now arrived in Antalya to start cutting the text down. Chris Bowen, the Australian minister presiding over the talks, admitted: “The first draft will look very different to the final draft.”

At the opening leaders’ summit, Hilda Heine, president of the Marshall Islands, warned: “Our response to the threat of overshoot must be overwhelming, or the world we know is over.” The UN secretary general, António Guterres, put it more bluntly: “It’s make or bake time.” Yet only 91 national leaders attended, and Donald Trump and Xi Jinping were among those absent.

The Guardian’s editorial argued that those pushing for a faster shift away from fossil fuels “are on the side of the future, while their opponents are stuck in the past”.

What do you want to know about what’s happening in Antalya? Can a summit co-hosted by an oil-producing Turkey and a coal-exporting Australia get a fossil-fuel phaseout over the line? Is 1.5C now out of reach, and what does “overshoot” really mean for the countries most at risk? And with the US government absent, who is leading?

Fiona Harvey and Ajit Niranjan will be live here at 5pm GMT (12pm EST) on Tuesday, 17 November to answer your questions on the talks, the draft deal and what comes next.

Post your questions in the comments below or email [email protected]

Share

Updated at 

Key events

How do long-term climate targets survive short-term politics?

Choo_choo asks: How can the long term requirements of climate change be matched to the short term political cycle? It seems like leaders can sign up to targets safe in the knowledge that they will have most likely departed the scene by the time the targets should have been achieved. Even just a few years shows massive political change. For instance Cop26 in 2021 had Joe Biden, Boris Johnson, Angela Merkel and Mario Draghi front and centre.

Fiona: The leaders depart, but most of their parties endure, and voters can – and should – punish parties that fail to keep their promises on the climate.

Ajit: The signal that these targets send is significant, as companies have to make investment decisions in an uncertain world. If a carmaker sees a national pledge to cut domestic emissions, and believes it will result in higher pollution taxes or bans on combustion engines, it has more incentive to start ramping up production of EVs. Unfortunately, these companies also lobby against such policies, and in some cases are rewarded with policy rollbacks. This is doubly frustrating for climate action, as it penalises the companies that did comply while reducing faith in future targets.

In the long run, though, the direction has been clearly set, and the fight is now largely about when, and how fast, polluters will be forced to clean up their act. For some communities, the answer to that question is existential.

Share

#climate #experts #Ajit #Niranjan #Fiona #Harvey #answer #questions #Cop31 #live #Environment