So much for the death of wokeness. Last night’s simmering mob at Oriel College, Oxford surely put paid to all the giddy obituaries for PC. For here they were once more, the self-righteous shock troops of the cult of fragility, hollering for the silencing of a man whose views ‘hurt’ them. Their target? Self-styled ‘race realist’ Nathan Cofnas. Their methods? The usual: noise, menace, shoving, assault and shamelessly weaponised self-pity. It was like 2020 all over again.

Judging by the wailing of the assembled censors, you’d be forgiven for thinking Cofnas had been invited to give a talk on the need for new Nuremberg Laws while trussed up like a Temu Hitler. ‘Nazi scum!’, the mob chanted. ‘Racist cunts!’, they yelled at attendees of his talk. Real charmers. In fact, all Cofnas was addressing, at the invitation of the university’s Reform Society, was the question: ‘Is DEI undermining higher education?’ And apparently, only 40 people turned up to hear him. At ease, everyone – Nazism isn’t about to march on London.

No sooner had it been announced that Cofnas would be visiting Oriel than fainting couches were being wheeled out across Oxford. He’s controversial, certainly. He’s part of the ‘hereditarian revolution’, which posits that genetic differences explain the disparities in IQ between racial groups. He became the digital mob’s top pantomime villain off the back of the Jason Arday affair. He was among the first to blow the whistle on Arday’s fabulist backstory and his academic charlatanism that landed him a cushy professorship at Cambridge. When Arday killed himself in August, the activist set outrageously accused Cofnas and the media more broadly of having ‘lynched’ him.

Indeed, one of the main slurs yelled at Cofnas last night was that he is a killer. ‘Rest in Power, Jason Arday’, placards said, to drive home the horror of his ‘lyncher’ being allowed into Oriel. The craft-beer tossers of Led By Donkeys protested Cofnas’s appearance by putting a KKK hood on Oriel’s statue of Cecil Rhodes, alongside a sign saying: ‘Racists welcome here.’ Serial case-loser Jolyon Maugham of the Good Law Project described Cofnas as the man ‘principally responsible’ for Arday’s death.

Such shrill accusations might be deranged and possibly defamatory. But they also beautifully capture the twin ideologies that fuel the zombie monster of wokeness. First, that words are violence – they wound, they kill. And secondly, that ethnic minorities are such fragile creatures, so woefully bereft of the moral agency enjoyed by the majority community, that they can never be held responsible for their actions. In the mad cry that Cofnas killed Arday, we glimpse the toxic brew of intolerance and pity that motivates the 21st-century ‘progressive’, for whom truth-seeking is violence and black people are pathetic.


Enjoying spiked?

Why not make an instant, one-off donation?

We are funded by you. Thank you!




Please wait…

‘Protect Black Students’ was the title of the anti-Cofnas petition that garnered 32,000 signatures. Oriel should consider its ‘safeguarding responsibilities’ towards black scholars, it said, as if ethnic-minority folk at Oxford are overgrown infants requiring baby-proofing from ‘dangerous’ ideas. Photographer and woke moaner Misan Harriman gave a speech saying Oxford has a ‘duty of care’ to its students, which apparently includes forcefielding the poor dears from alternative thinking. The Reform Society is a ‘danger to black students’, said another speaker. When Oriel said anyone who is offended by Cofnas should simply not attend his talk – a dangerously sensible suggestion – activists insisted his venomous ideas would spread beyond the lecture hall and ‘harm’ all black students, because they’ll be ‘asking themselves how much the university cares about them’.

The irony is too much: they accuse Cofnas of infantilising black people as a low-IQ population even as they infantilise black people as hyper-vulnerable individuals requiring official protection from thought, from words. Cofnas once infamously said that if universities ditched DEI and enforced a strict meritocracy, there’d be virtually no black academics. That’s grossly offensive, no doubt. Yet so is the idea that black kids at Oxford are such porcelain beings, so liable to be wounded by words, that the very thought of Cofnas being on campus is enough to propel them into a night of anguish. It’s the same idea, in fact. Cofnas says blacks aren’t clever enough for uni, his haters imply they lack the intellectual backbone for uni, which by definition involves exposure to difficult ideas. The bigotry of ‘low IQ’ vs the bigotry of low expectations.

On the cobbles of Oriel we saw how swiftly the cult of fragility can turn violent. How naturally the twin creeds of censoriousness and condescension lend themselves to physical-force bullying. Attendees of Cofnas’s talk were not only called ‘cunts’ – some were threatened and shoved into brick walls. Masked men prevented people from getting inside, hence the small audience of 40. Pro-Cofnas protesters were physically assaulted. Local cops say they’re investigating ‘multiple assaults’, including one against an officer.

Such thuggery is a natural outgrowth of the therapeutic mania of the modern campus. It is the violence of the Safe Space. For when you train an entire generation to conceive of words as weapons, and their fragile egos as the target, you inevitably nurture a culture of hair-trigger paranoia. Tell pampered young adults that a heterodox lecture is an act of physical aggression, and they will naturally treat the speaker like an armed intruder – not merely someone they disagree with but someone who poses a threat to their very psychic safety. Teaching the young to sacralise their emotional prestige above all else, and to view everything from ‘misgendering’ to ‘race realism’ as a dire threat to that prestige, was always going to whip up dread, hysteria and panicked menace.

All this talk of ‘duty of care’ is so slippery. The only ‘duty of care’ a university has to its students is to throw them in the deep end of human knowledge, with all its great, mad and confronting ideas, and trust that they’ll be able to navigate a way through. Letting Cofnas speak at Oriel was wholly in keeping with that duty of care. If you disagree with Cofnas, say so. Write something, deliver an alternative lecture, invite Cofnas to debate you. That’s what I intend to do with the lingering intellectual cancer of wokeness: not punch its practitioners in the head, but explain why their inquisitorial zeal and racialised pity are a menace to the pursuit of knowledge and the dream of equality.



#Nathan #Cofnas #violent #cult #fragility