Two irreconcilable facts were always jostling for influence in Alan Milburn’s review of the UK’s youth unemployment and welfare crisis. The first is that something has to be done about the one million 16- to 24-year-olds who are not in employment, education or training (NEET), many of whom are living off welfare. The second is that the vast majority of Labour MPs are opposed to any attempt to reduce welfare spending. Indeed, the last time the Labour government tried to get a handle on welfare spending in the summer of 2025, it failed so catastrophically that then chancellor Rachel Reeves nearly had a nervous breakdown in parliament. On Tuesday, when Milburn’s report was published, it was clear which of these competing influences won out.
Milburn’s 278-page review into the NEETs crisis is basically one long admission that a Labour government will not be able to reform the UK’s financially ruinous and morally indefensible welfare system. Milburn, a Labour health secretary under Tony Blair, has recommended that the government shift young people off the two key sickness and disability benefits – the health element of universal credit and personal independence payments (PIP). But this is only to allow the government to move them on to a new benefit system, featuring a youth allowance that will be paid at the standard rate of universal credit, an additional cost allowance that will replace PIP, and a ‘severe and complex needs insurance’. At this stage, the new system of benefits looks like a rebranded version of the old one.
Certainly, any savings it will achieve – Milburn claims it will reduce welfare spending by £3.6 billion a year – will be wiped out by another of his recommendations: a hefty investment in various employment-support schemes. Milburn has put this figure at slightly less than £6 billion a year.
Even if Milburn’s reforms came to pass, they wouldn’t save any money for at least 10 years. Even then, the savings would amount to only £200million a year, which is the equivalent of about five hours’ worth of welfare spending at current levels.
Not that this has put the dampeners on the government’s spin operation. UK prime minister Andy Burnham has described Milburn’s report as a ‘watershed moment’. Milburn himself claims it is a ‘complete reset’ that, if followed through, will save a ‘lost generation’ from worklessness. But no amount of hyperbole can alter the fact that the welfare state will remain as bloated as ever.
That Milburn’s report is an admission of defeat becomes particularly clear when he turns to the question of the UK’s youth mental-health ‘crisis’, which is regularly cited as one of the many reasons why young people are unable to work. Indeed, the majority of young people claiming PIP do so on mental-health or neurodevelopmental grounds – in other words, because they have anxiety, depression, ADHD or autism.
Milburn’s review does nothing to reckon with or interrogate the spectacular growth of mental-health diagnoses in recent years. Instead, he just accepts this as normal, a fact of modern life. He promises more ‘support’ for young people who are waiting for a diagnosis, and a ‘maximum waiting time’ for youths seeking mental-health services. That is, he is reaffirming the fiction that today’s youth are mentally less capable of work than preceding generations, due to various psychological conditions and disorders. They are too ‘nervous’, or too sad, or too anxious or they struggle to focus. And unless they receive the support they supposedly need – support that the UK’s healthcare system cannot possibly meet – their only option is to subsist on state handouts for as long as they live.
Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised by the tepidness of Milburn’s review. Burnham has consistently said that he would not oversee ‘crude cuts’ to the welfare system – a phrase repeated often by Milburn himself. The problem is that what a Labour politician defines as a ‘crude’ cut seems to apply to any reduction in welfare spending at all.
We learnt this last summer. Reeves, the then chancellor, tried to trim a paltry £5 billion annually off the government’s £333 billion welfare bill. She was forced to amend the reforms not once, but twice – until she agreed not to take a single penny out of the welfare system. Keir Starmer’s premiership never recovered, and Reeves was reduced to a trembling, humiliated and tearful wreck during Prime Minister’s Questions. A career politician such as Burnham was never going to risk the ire of the Parliamentary Labour Party, the very people who ousted his predecessor and installed him in No10.
But Britain no longer has the luxury of tinkering with the status quo. Welfare spending now exceeds income-tax revenue. On average, 1,000 people a day are being placed on PIP. In more than 3,000 neighbourhoods across the country, the majority of adults are claiming out-of-work benefits. According to Milburn, 1.3million young people – one in six – will be NEET by 2031 unless the system is reformed. Yet the Labour government can do little about it, because its MPs will not stand for it.
There is one obvious reason for this: the only way in which today’s predominantly middle-class Labour Party can relate to the working-class communities it formerly represented is through welfarism. It sees people living in communities decimated by deindustrialisation principally as wards of the state. Instead of seeking to provide people with gainful, decent-paying employment, Labour prefers to pity and look after them instead.
The economic costs of welfarism are mounting. Yet the moral costs are just as severe. Young people who are able to work but don’t do so are unlikely to ever discover their passion in life. Certainly, they will never know the simple, instinctive satisfactions of routine, responsibility and financial independence. Generally speaking, people on welfare do not live happy or fulfilled lives.
This cannot be the society we want to live in. Yet it is the society that Labour’s addiction to welfare is creating right before our very eyes. Alan Milburn’s review has missed a golden opportunity to put us on the right track.
#Milburn #review #promises #welfarism